TPA and wealth: acknowledging the challenges, amplifying the benefits

The case for a Total Portfolio Approach (TPA) is relatively simple to articulate. Start from the investor’s objectives, look across the whole portfolio, and let every investment compete for capital against every other.

Wealth management may complicate this picture – risk profiles, tax, wrappers, platforms, product structures and thousands of individual accounts all contribute to a portfolio more difficult to deliver in practice.

TPA in wealth remains at an early stage, and perhaps the challenges are higher than for institutional investors. Even so, elements of the approach can sharpen and enable how wealth portfolios are built, by testing whether each allocation, each unit of risk and each pound of fees is still pulling its weight.

Acknowledging the practical challenges

  • Is TPA really different? Good strategic asset allocation (SAA) already starts with objectives, considers factor exposures and adapts as conditions change. Acknowledging this overlap is an important first step, but it can weaken the rationale for adopting TPA as a distinct framework.
  • Governance and organisational demand and change. Full adoption goes beyond investment decisions, potentially requiring resource-intensive changes to governance, team structures, systems and decision rights, as well as suitability and compliance processes.
  • Suitability and risk-profiling constraints. Prescribed volatility bands and client risk labels can limit portfolio flexibility required under a TPA framework – even when changes improve diversification. Reducing volatility can itself move a portfolio into a different risk-profile category.
  • Tax, wrapper and platform compatibility. Attractive investments from a TPA perspective may not work efficiently within ISAs, SIPPs or available platform structures. Essentially, an investment idea has less practical value if clients cannot hold it efficiently.
  • Implementation at scale. Derivatives, long-short strategies or currency trades are harder to replicate across large numbers of retail accounts, with associated tax and operational burdens. Portfolio turnover can consequently be slower than in institutional portfolios.
  • Cost, complexity and liquidity trade-offs. Diversifying exposures must fit acceptable fee budgets, liquidity requirements and usable product structures. Alternatives need not mean expensive hedge funds or illiquid private markets, but stronger resilience can still bring greater complexity and somewhat less liquidity.
  • Client understanding and conviction. Clients’ comparisons with equity indices or cheap passive funds can undermine support for diversified, objectives-led portfolios, particularly when equities perform strongly. Continuous communication about the client’s objectives becomes even more crucial.
  • Bespoke needs versus scalability. Differing income, retirement and inheritance objectives complicate a standardised portfolio approach, creating a tension between tailoring solutions to individual clients and delivering them at scale.

Amplifying the benefits and enablers

  • Returning to the desired objective. TPA reinforces the discipline of returning to client objectives, rather than treating the current allocation as the starting point. If 10% sits in credit, it asks whether credit still deserves 10% at all. For example more attractive government-bond yields illustrate why safer fixed income paired with equities may offer a better total-portfolio risk profile.
  • Whole-portfolio risk and fee analysis. Capital weights, risk contributions and fee budgets often differ significantly. TPA makes these differences clearer: a portfolio can look diversified by capital while equity drives most of its risk and fundamental active equity absorbs a large share of manager fees.
  • Making fee budgets work harder. A whole-portfolio view tests what each pound of fees is buying. Trimming expensive fundamental active equity, moving towards lower-cost quantitative management and directing savings towards diversifying strategies can strengthen resilience while keeping overall cost broadly neutral.
  • Broadening the toolkit for whole-portfolio diversification. Liquid alternatives, quantitative investment strategies and alternative risk premia offer potential routes beyond costly hedge funds or illiquid private markets. They enable TPA by giving wealth managers more options to assess against client objectives and the portfolio’s overall risk, liquidity and fee budgets – not simply to fill an alternatives allocation.
  • Putting implementation first. Tax, wrappers, suitability and platform constraints belong at the start of portfolio design, so investment ideas can be put into practice within clients’ existing arrangements.
  • Building blocks that support scale. Building-block funds can combine bespoke portfolio design with scalability: investment teams manage sophisticated exposures within a small number of vehicles, which can be simpler to run than a long list of individual funds. Advisers can combine these components around client objectives, enabling elements of TPA without redesigning the entire wealth architecture.
  • Designing around the client. One retiree relies on portfolio income, another has substantial defined-benefit income, and a third prioritises inheritance or gifting. Advisers can assess these objectives and cash-flow needs, then combine a manageable set of investment building blocks – potentially alongside guaranteed-income or annuity-type components – into a total portfolio tailored to each client.
  • Explaining the process. Advisers connect the portfolio to the client’s broader financial objectives. Explaining the process alongside quarterly returns helps maintain conviction in diversification and reminds clients what they hired the manager to achieve.

A discipline for wealth portfolios

For now, TPA is most useful in wealth as a discipline for repeatedly questioning the portfolio, with SAA still providing the backbone. Does each allocation deserve its capital? Is this where the next pound of fees and risk add most to the whole? Is the portfolio serving the client’s objectives?

Suitability, tax, wrappers, platforms, cost and communication may make total portfolio thinking harder to apply in wealth, but more rewarding to get right.